In February, Julep offered 3 versions of the mystery box you could choose from. Each box was $24.99 and promised to have $75 worth of product in it.
1) Mani Lover
2) Pedi Lover
3) Makeup Lover
They also offered a $10 add-on worth >$40. When I read the description it made it sound like there would be no dupicates so why not order all of the boxes. I was curious and decided to order all of them, two with the mystery add-on, and one with an add-on for a color I just thought was pretty when the add-on page popped up.
Here is what I got (in the order I received them)...
BOX 1: MAKEUP LOVER
This box's included color was Lindy. This box was pretty small, but it did not
Included Polish: Blank Canvas Mattifying Eye Primer ($22.00/$17.60)
Sweep Eyeshadow Palette - Neutrals ($24.00/$19.20)
1 oz. Rock Star Hand Cream
Julep Lengthening Mascara - Brown (on sale $12.99)
Polish in addition to Lindy:
America the Beautiful (on sale $2.99)
Nan (on sale $2.99)
With Maven prices, the mani box comes out to $66.97 plus what the 1 oz. Rock Star hand cream would be (I am assuming 1/4 of the full price so $4 for Mavens making the total $70.97). Non-maven prices gets you to $78.97 plus the value of the hand cream (and assuming it's $5 that puts the total to $83.97). Sale prices are used to calculate value not original prices which you will obviously see that used to calculate the value of add-ons.
BOX 2: PEDI LOVER
This box's included color was Aphrodite. Description: "
This Cupid's Mystery Box is packed with $75 of pedi-themed polish and product, including a bottle of Aphrodite - Classic with a Twist, a rose with silver metallic micro glitter."
The add-ons were on the top:
Products:
Double Step ($22.00/$17.60 Maven)
Mint Condition Pedi Creme ($20.00/$16.00 Maven)
Foot File ($6.00/$4.80 Maven)
Polish in addition to Aphrodite (which I am assuming $14.00/$11.20 Maven):
Claudette (on sale $4.99)
Karen (on sale $2.99)
Add-on:
Stefani (on sale $6.99)
Angela (on sale$6.99)
Kennedy (on sale $3.99)
The sum of these add-ons is only $17.97 so I wouldn't consider this to be over $40 worth of product.
MY ADD ON: Karen (on sale $2.99)
The value of the pedi box came out to be $57.58 for maven prices (including sale prices). For non-mavens (and including sale prices), the total comes out to $69.98. Not $75 either way - just like the add-on.
BOX 3: MANI LOVER
This box came with Venus as the included color.
Add-on colors pulled out from top of box...they look familiar...
The layer underneath with the mani goods:
The beauty items in this box:
1 oz. Rock Star hand cream
Nail file
Freedom Polymer Topcoat ($18.00/$14.40 Maven)
Mighty Cuticle & Nail Serum ($28.00/$22.40 Maven)
The other colors (besides Venus which is assumed to be $14.00/$11.20 Maven) in this box:
America the Beautiful ($2.99 sale)
Bette ($6.99 sale)
Madison ($14.00/$11.20 Maven)
The value of this box comes out to $69.18 plus the value of the hand cream and nail file. The value using non-maven prices comes out to $83.98 plus the value of the nail file and hand cream. Makes the duplicates from the make-up box more forgivable when you look at it from that point of view.
SUMMARY
There were a few things that annoyed me about the Cupid's Mystery Boxes:
1. There were duplicates in the Makeup & Mani boxes of America the Beautiful & the Rock Star hand cream.
2. The $10 mystery add-on was the same for two different boxes. I was hoping they would be more box unique. I was also hoping that they would be worth $40 as advertised. The sale prices mean I could have just gone out and purchased the add-ons for $17.97. Furthermore, since I got two identical sets, I paid more than that and now have polish to give away.
3. I feel like they just got rid of a bunch of old polish that was already on sale. If this is the case, I think the sale prices should be accounted for in the value of boxes although only one box fell short of that if you looked at non-maven prices (just like monthly boxes are valued at over $40 for 3 polishes because non-maven prices is $14 even though maven prices are $11.20).
4. I had the option to add on Karen when I got my pedi lover box and did but then it was included in the box. It was irritating to get two of the same polish in my box. If they knew they were offering that color I with they could not include it in available add-ons.
Would I recommend a mystery box? Probably if you didn't have many Julep products, liked taking chances, and/or especially if you liked a special color like they did in these boxes (and have again in March). I have not ordered a March mystery box yet. March boxes have a value of $100 for $24.99 with a $9.99 add-on worth $42 or a $14.99 add-on worth $63. Tempting, isn't it?? Yeah...there is a good chance I will go there. Just checked - the $14.99 add-on at checkout is out of stock!
*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
If you aren't a Julep Maven and want to become one, use
this link to take the style quiz and the promo code FREEBOX to get your first box for free! You just have to pay shipping or buy $10 in their great deal add-ons to get free shipping.